Tell them a joke
This one is the classic approach to a genuine reaction. If you don't know any good jokes, ask your kid for a joke. Crack a joke about yourself. Just start laughing like someone told you the funniest joke even if no one told one. Laughter is infectious and sparks more laughter. If your joke falls flat, that can also provide a hilarious genuine reaction, perhaps the opposite of joy.
Whisper something sweet
This one is my teacher trick. We often forget the power of shifting our volume. Sometimes when we have high hopes for a specific outcome...*cough* a genuine portrait* cough*...kids can sense the stress in our voices, tone, and volume. Making sure we keep our tone playful and varying our volume level can work wonders. A whisper voice can shift a kiddos mood and help them show up as themselves in front of the lens.
Set them up with a favorite stuffed animal or toy
This one is really powerful if you have a quieter, more introverted kiddo. If they have their comfort item, they will feel a bit more safe to interact with you and your camera.
Put on their favorite songs
You know your kid best and if they can't sit still during their favorite song, then this may not work for a genuine portrait. But, if their favorite song usually elicits a genuine reaction and they still sit still, go for it!
Play pretend!
Use your imagination together! My favorite trick when I was photographing a cooperative preschool last year was pretending the chair the kids were to sit on was a rocket ship. This worked wonders for those reluctant kiddos.
Photograph them in their own environment.
The best way to get kids comfortable is to put them on their own turf. Maybe they are in front of their mirror or on their own bed or at their desk. As a kid my family would do extended family portraits at a studio and this rarely got a genuine personality filled portrait of any of us. This is also because back then the photographers didn't get to know us. It was just about posing and lighting. Now I always ask for a questionnaire of my clients and recommend that sessions begin at home where everyone is comfortable. If I'm on location with a family, I always start with a conversation with each kiddo to build rapport and respect before expecting anything from them.
Use natural light.
Place your child near a window or open door. Garage light is amazing for portraits. Make sure the light gets caught in their eyes. Without those catchlights, people’s personalities seem dull.
Be sarcastic and refer to pop culture.
This one is for your older kids. While 6-7 might not work anymore, you may get away with a little sarcastic humor or references to their drip or who has rizz lately. ;-)
Keep portraits valuable by putting your phone or camera away after a few minutes.
There is a fine line between wanting to document it all and actually documenting it all. Kids need time and space without a camera in their face. Put your phone down after a few minutes and just be present. The more often you do this, the more willing kids will be to show up as themselves in your portrait sessions.
Finally, time the portrait session appropriately.
Never attempt a portrait session when a kiddo is overtired or hungry. Also, if you have hopes to do them regularly...be sure to space them out enough. You may create a portrait tradition around specific holidays or points in the school year.
Feel overwhelmed? Not getting the reaction you want?
Sometimes you could be doing everything right to try for genuine portraits, but you are still their parent, and they won't cooperate with you. Sometimes a kiddo needs a third party, an unrelated person to respond to. That's why professional in-home photographers are helpful. That's where I come in. I am a lifestyle and documentary real-life family and newborn photographer in the Seattle area who loves getting genuine portraits of kiddos. Let's chat as I'd be happy to help you achieve your vision!